Explaining Why the GOP Lost so Badly

Editor’s Note: This post was delayed by the worldwide Microsoft outage a few days ago. I really tried to download and edit this post but could not access it. I’m squeezing in some time to edit things while working around other activities.

Well, I cannot say I did not warn you.  I wrote in this space multiple times that the election would be rough, however; I will admit I did not see that result coming. While I felt a tidal wave was building, I did not for see a category five hurricane.

I will explain below the reasons the GOP did this to themselves.  Believe it or not, the Democrats didn’t win as much as the GOP lost.

  1.  Cost of living/tariffs.  Trump and the GOP made a promise to lower prices/costs if given control of Congress and the White House.  They failed.  Now I will admit lowering costs is very hard to do legislatively, but they took the wrong approach.  Making a promise you cannot keep ends badly, like Tuesday’s results.  Then they decided to go the tariff route, and for what reason I am unsure.  However, it exposed those in the GOP who are clueless on economic issues. Most I spoke with had no idea what a tariff even is.  I then asked them to research which political party supported tariffs in the past…. Hint it is not the GOP.  The tariffs actually raised prices, and worse yet, other countries quit buying our products, creating issues here.  The last point here is the tariffs were a “sliding scale” that Trump changed whenever he wanted based on whether you appeased him.  When you move the goal post constantly others do not want to play with you.

Trump promising a $2,000 per person tariff check last year that never happened and then he promised $5,000 if Republicans kept control of Congress on November 3rd. Absolutely stupid, tone deaf, and unconstitutional.

  • The Iran War.  This is deeply unpopular with everyone except the neo-cons.  We were told repeatedly by Trump during his campaign he would not start a war, he was going to end one. (Ukraine v Russia).  It was Kamala who was going to get us into World War 3.   Instead, we have a full-blown conflict on our hands and no real exit strategy.  The Strait of Hormuz is blocked, and gas prices have soared.  Regardless of your thoughts on the war, the gas price drove people to the polls.
  • Bad Candidates.  I already wrote about Ken Paxton in Texas in this space and how he had a lot of skeletons in his closet.  Paxton is the person who no one really likes, and I am of the belief he brought the whole ticket down in Texas.  The Governor lost, and we lost a few house seats. (More on that later).  Vivek Ramaswamy in Ohio was another horrific candidate.  He spoke about H1B visas (importing foreign workers to replace American workers) data centers, and AI.  I know he is smarter than this, but his lack of reading a room is astonishing.  Those beliefs will play in Silicon Valley, and perhaps other places, but not Ohio.  He also ran the worst attack ad of the cycle against his opponent.  It was so bad that essentially every Republican in Ohio denounced it and said pull it off the air.  Oh, check out congressman Max Miller who ran for re-election in Ohio.  He was accused of physically abusing his wife, and daughter. He refused to drop out and lost a safe seat.  Like Texas, I believe Ramaswamy and Miller brought the whole ticket down as we lost the governorship here as well.
  • Name calling.  Folks I will admit I did enjoy the first time Trump ran for president.  Lyin Ted, Little Marco, Crooked Hillary it was somewhat funny.  It has run its course, now Trump comes off looking like an 11 year old playground bully.  Trump called Abdul El Sayed who won a senate seat in Michigan a jihadist.  Yeah, you read that correctly.  Sayed is an antisemite who has no business being near the Senate, but he won because Trump could not get out of his own way.  He was elected in spite of Trump.  Look him up, he is bad news.  Trump and Paxton called James Talarico in Texas “Transgender Talarico.”  Again, this likely contributed to him scoring an upset, people do not like to hear others call people names.  Truth is, the GOP should drop this issue as a “leading issue.”  We have Sophie Cunningham and Riley Gaines to carry this proverbial cross.  Find another issue.
  • Lazy candidates.  I will be honest I came to this conclusion as an opinion more so then a scientific finding.  We lost Senate seats in Mississippi and Kansas where sitting incumbents should have won.  (Blogger’s Note: at press time the race in Mississippi has not been called but the incumbent is losing by 3,000 votes.)  These are races that should have been called for the incumbent shortly after the polls closed.  Instead in Kansas we lost the seat by around 5% or so.  My opinion, these incumbents got in and figured they had a seat until they wanted to give it up, or were wheeled out with a toe tag on their foot and in a black bag with a zipper.  In both cases, I think entitlement sank in and as a result both are likely to lose.
  • Redistricting backfired.  Where were the pickups in Texas?  Florida?  They never materialized.  Ditto for North Carolina and Ohio.  The pick-ups Trump envisioned never happened.  How come?  What most do not understand when you re-draw the lines it is not just about “partisan lean” aka percentage of Democrat vs Republican voters.  It is about getting them to actually vote for you.  This costs a lot of $$$ as opposed to your old district where you could essentially coast to re-election.  In addition, the Republican gerrymander was sold as “a way to eliminate Democrats” but in some states it targeted the black member, or a large population of black people’s cities.  I believe this drove black turnout to massive highs compared to the past.  Mississippi Senate seat, Tennessee governor race, a seat in Tennessee, two seats in Louisiana, Texas as a whole.  Check the results folks, it backfired badly. 
  • Hair on fire voter fraud claims.  They started before the election, with Trump leading the chorus.  While I believe fraud exists, folks, most of these electoral loses by incumbents were between 5-8%.  That is outside the margin of lawyers and voter fraud, sorry.  Your argument holds no water.  As I have stated in the past, show me actual proof of the fraud, not a conspiracy theory.  The losses were not due to fraud (Alaska Senate is the exception). 
  • Lack of legislative accomplishments.  Outside of the Big Beautiful Bill, name one.  Oh yeah, you can’t.  Because it does not exist, this literally was a do-nothing Congress.  Why should I vote GOP?  They gave us no reason to.
  • Releasing opposition research too early.  This one cost us big time this cycle.  We dropped the bombshell report about Eric Swalwell, the favorite to be the next governor of California at the time, allowing Xavier Beccera to overtake him in the primary.  Am I saying Hilton would have won against Swalwell? Nope.  Would the race have been closer and maybe provided a chance for a couple down ticket races to maybe go our way?  I say yes.  Swalwell’s accusations tend to suppress turnout and that has ramifications.  The second example is Graham Platner in Maine. This guy has more skeletons in his closet than a graveyard.  Even though it was after the primary, enough time was available for the Democrats to find a new nominee.  Joe Biden was just a trial run, but this party does not learn it’s lesson, ever.  You wait until the ballots are printed for the general to do a big dump like they did on Platner.  Collins wins easily if we wait, one less seat lost. 

The next blog will be about how to rebuild the party.

The Chief

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *